Join The NonProfit Times: or Become a member

Subscribe: Print Publication or Newsletter

Stay connected.
Stay informed.

Live From DMA: Direct Mail Hiatus Cost ACS $30 Million

By Mark Hrywna - August 5, 2015

New donors declined by 11 percent and new donor revenue dropped by $11.3 million in the first year that American Cancer Society (ACS) paused its direct mail acquisition program. Over five years, the hiatus would have had a projected impact of $29.5 million to the organization.

The Atlanta, Ga.-based charity offered perspectives on its re-entry into mail during a presentation titled “Direct Mail Acquisition – Engine for Growth or Treadmill for Survival?” The 45-minute session took place during the second day of the Direct Marketing Association Nonprofit Federation’s New York Nonprofit Conference today at the New York Hilton.

ACS suspended its direct mail acquisition program in January 2013 amid a three-year transformation that consolidated the nearly billion-dollar organization from 13 separate divisions into one single 501(c)(3) entity. Direct mail acquisition was relaunched in June 2014.

Catharine Holihan has been director of direct marketing at ACS for six months, after a tenure as customer engagement manager. She led the panel that also included Lauren Ashcraft, senior consultant, direct mail renewal, Peggy Jaynes, senior consultant, direct mail, acquisition, ACS, and representatives from its marketing agency, Merkle, including Jeff Patrick, chief strategy officer and vice president, nonprofit, and Senior Vice President Jennifer Quinlan.

“Traditional legacy channels get a lot of pressure to continue to perform, so for a lot of us, direct mail is the bulk of revenue for direct response programs,” Holihan said. Four direct mail programs raise about 80 percent of direct response revenue for ACS.

In late 2012, the decision was made to pause the direct mail acquisition program for 2013. Historically, ACS was very siloed by channels, Holihan said. Prior to transformation, each division decided its own level of participation. “The important question became: How are we doing to reinvent the direct mail program to align with the organization’s new priorities,” Holihan said.

In 2012, ACS generated 252,000 new donors through its $10 million investment in the direct mail acquisition program. Multi-year donors generate 45 to 48 percent of total revenue, which peaked in 2008 at about $1.2 billion.

“It’s tempting to look at things through a one-year lens but the runway for direct mail acquisition is much longer than that. For every $1 we invest in direct mail acquisition, we bring in $7 over the course of three years,” Holihan said. “We need acquisition to feed the core audience or else the entire program loses profitably through the course of the natural customer cycle,” she said.

“It was understood that immediately, direct mail acquisition revenue was going to decline and we also knew revenue across other direct mail programs would decrease over time,” Ashcraft said. “What was apparent really quickly, our renewal program was impacted immediately as well,” she said, adding that direct mail feeds other programs like planned giving and events. At their peak, direct mail donors accounted for more than 10 percent of contributors to ACS’ Relay For Life, which last year raised $355 million, $25 million less than the previous year. Direct mail donors give more than $51 million to planned giving.

The pause in direct mail acquisition would impact beyond ACS and into the sector as a whole since direct mail lists and co-ops are interconnected. “There will be speculation around why we did this, what happened. Ultimately, we trust our leadership and we take the responsibility to do the best we can with what we have,” Ashcraft said.

The goal for 2014 was  to increase overall revenue by 12 percent. “We knew we needed to re-start direct mail acquisition as part of the marketing mix,” Holihan said. ACS started with a goal to bring in 125,000 new donors for 2014 at a cost per dollar raised (CPDR) of $1.05. The organization surpassed both goals, bringing in 136,000 new donors at $0.99 CPDR, in addition to beating its $4.4 million fundraising goal by $300,000. For only six months, July to December, ACS brought in $571,000 at $0.30 CPDR, according to Holihan.

Digital and email channels may be less expensive but it became evident that it would take longer to break even and fill the funnel, Jaynes said. “These channels weren’t necessarily going to fill the funnel as quickly as direct mail had,” she said.“It had to be a multichannel strategy to come back.”

Suspending direct mail and expecting to replace donors through the online channel may not respect what actual direct mail donors’ wishes are, according to Holihan.

ACS “reinvented the program and implemented an integrated strategy – not just direct mail – we’re digital, we’re email, we’re telefundraising,” Ashcraft said. “We’re focusing on net revenue efficiency and high-value donors,” she said.

The hiatus was a “strategic decision to orient our fundraising programs to maximize revenue from existing donor audiences, grow into new ones, and rethink how we were doing things,” Holihan said.

“The transformation really opened the door for communication not just in marketing team but across the organization. This dialogue was critical. Our finance team could actually talk about our marketing programs when we’re not in the room,” Holihan said. “Conventional wisdom doesn’t always apply. To step back and look at programs with fresh eyes helps greatly; test different things, see what will work for your organization,” she said.

“A conservative approach can work, I think we’re living proof of that.”


Sponsored Podcasts

Welcome to the Raise & Engage podcast, a filters-off series for nonprofit professionals hosted by Blackbaud's straight-shooting expert Danielle Johnson Vermenton. During this open-mic session, you’ll hear honest advice to help YOU do more for your cause.

Episode 6: The Power of ‘No’ at Work|| daniellejohnson-76

You have a job description, but on any given day, you're probably doing dozens of things outside the scope of that description. Combine that with the challenge of a fast-paced environment and the shifting priorities of funders, colleagues, and board members and it’s easy to fall short of doing your best. By being mindful of your limitations and capacity—and saying “no” when your plate is full—you can actually do more for your cause. In the sixth installment of the Raise and Engage podcast Danielle Johnson and Robin Anderson discuss the power of saying “no” at work.

Episode 5: Professional Development: Getting Un-Stuck|| daniellejohnson-76

In the most recent episode of Raise + Engage, Danielle is back with Brian Reich from little m media to discuss how nonprofit professionals can stay motivated and energized in their day-to-day roles. Brian shares his experience working with nonprofits and the lessons and tips he's learn from and shared with them over the years, including tips for avoiding a professional rut, creating forward momentum in your career and pushing yourself outside of your comfort zone. If you're considering making a career move or want to ensure you're on the right path, you won't want to miss this inspo-packed episode!

Episode 4: Apps and Hacks to Stay (Mostly) Sane || daniellejohnson-76

Episode 4: Apps and Hacks to Stay (Mostly) Sane, is all about tips, tricks and tools for sanity. Blackbaud’s own interactive product marketer, Julia Lenz, joins host Danielle Johnson to share some high tech. (and no tech.) productivity tips to help nonprofit professionals stay sane in the crazy world of philanthropy.

Tune in to hear:

  • Tips for how to spend the first 30 minutes of your day
  • The benefits of 15 minute meetings
  • Why notebooks are still relevant to a successful organization
  • Ideas for better managing your inbox
  • Why you should take lunch outside the box
  • ...and much more!
Don’t forget to visit the #NoFilterNonprofit Hub afterwards to download our newest tip sheet10 Productivity Hacks for Nonprofits.

Episode 3: Tech. Connection: Solutions, Strategy, and Staff || daniellejohnson-76

Episode 3: Tech. Connection: Solutions, Strategy, and Staff In episode 3 of the Raise + Engage podcast, Danielle Johnson is joined by Chris Geady and William DaSilva, two IT experts in the nonprofit space, to talk technology integration for NPOs: when you need it, when you don’t, and how to do it successfully.

Tune in to hear:

  • When to say NO to integration
  • How to set your strategic plan before even looking at technologies
  • Ways to get your entire team on board
  • The importance of identifying a project lead
  • The RFP process - how it should and should not go
And William shares a story about a nonprofit that may or may not have still been using a typewriter. You don't want to miss this one!

Episode 2: From Socially Awkward to Socially Awesome! || daniellejohnson-76

According to Danielle Johnson, straight-shooting host of the Raise + Engage podcast series, if your staff members aren’t the number one advocates for your cause on social media, you’re failing. In the most recent episode, Danielle is joined by Blackbaud’s own social media guru Madeline Turner to discuss overcoming social struggles and creating a social ambassador program at your organization. This entertaining and insightful duo dishes on the importance of making your social media presence human, making the case for a formal social program to leadership, how University of Michigan turned a one time social media campaign into a long term social program, and how Madeline's mom unknowingly became a social ambassador on #GivingTuesday.

Episode 1: Corporate Culture & Development: Shake It Up! || daniellejohnson-76

In the premiere episode of Raise & Engage, Danielle is joined by three straight-shooting nonprofit rock-stars: Jodi Smith of Sanford Health Systems, Veronica Brown of Chicago Public Library Foundation and Ali Burke of Southlake Regional Health Centre Foundation. The group talks organizational culture, problem employees, why its important to celebrate and how to shake things up this year and build a better more authentic team that gets stuff done!


Stay informed, catch latest trends in the nonprofit space.

Subscribe to Our Free Newsletter

No obligation, unsubscribe at anytime.

Success! Check your email inbox.

Follow Us On Twitter

NPT 2016 Buyers' Guide

Newsletter Sign-up

click here to return to the previous page